The Victorian Aboriginal Legal Service (VALS) is deeply disappointed by yet another election commitment which politicises the wellbeing and safety of children. The Victorian Liberal Party have taken the cookie cutter approach and announced a failed Queensland approach as part of an uninspired policy platform for ‘a fresh start’.
Yesterday the leader of the opposition Jess Wilson announced that if elected, her party would introduce boot camps as an alternative to community corrections orders or other custodial sentences, on the site of a former prison near Shepparton. Ms Wilson said the program would include mandatory daily tasks including farm work, cleaning maintenance, cooking and education to instil ‘discipline and respect’ because according to the Liberals there needs to be consequences for action to allow children to access a second chance.
Rather than demonstrating it is open to evidence-based, culturally grounded and Aboriginal-led solutions, the Liberal party has shown it will rely on incarceration and punishment as the preferred political response to complex social challenges. Our children deserve more than recycled “tough-on-crime” rhetoric and responses. They deserve leadership from an incoming government that will invest in their wellbeing, recognises their potential and understands that genuine community safety is built through connection, opportunity and support — not more prison cells.
The Dhurringile Prison is itself a site of trauma with a history of a former prisoner of war camp, a rural training farm and most recently a prison that was closed only two years ago. Genuine rehabilitation cannot be achieved by replicating the very institutional structures that perpetuate trauma, disconnection and disadvantage. Any interventions and supports for our young people should be health and welfare led. The evidence is clear, locking children up doesn’t work.
Out of sight, out of mind is not how we should be supporting our most vulnerable children. In Queensland concerns have been raised about how the recently passed ‘circuit breaker’ legislation also included that it could be a reasonable excuse for a provider not to report harm if it would incriminate them. This is an alarming lack of transparency and accountability that will only lead to further harming already vulnerable children. Why the Liberal party felt inspired by this approach is beyond concerning.
Our children deserve policies grounded in evidence, not election slogans. They deserve governments willing to invest in their futures, rather than political parties prepared to sacrifice those futures for votes.
Quotes Attributable to Nerita Waight, CEO of the Victorian Aboriginal Legal Service:
“The last I checked, Australia does not have compulsory military service, so why do we think boot camps for children are a sound idea? Will children involved in these camps be paid for their labour, receive certifications for skills developed, accrue superannuation? As these are the elements alongside therapeutic supports and interventions that would actually see opportunities for a better life, otherwise this is akin to slave labour.”
“I am disappointed but not surprised by yesterday’s announcement. On the day I was celebrating my eldest child’s birthday I am yet again confronted by a political party that does not understand child development, the impact of trauma, and that you cannot punish children into submission. We have a long history of child labour camps in this country, the harmful effects well documented in the Bringing Them Home Report and Yoorrook, I implore all Victorian political parties not to replicate a practice that is so dehumanising.”